Publication: Los derechos homínidos. Una defensa ecuménica
Authors
CASAL, PAULA
item.page.secondaryauthor
item.page.director
Publisher
Universidad de Murcia
publication.page.editor
publication.page.department
DOI
item.page.type
info:eu-repo/semantics/article
Description
Abstract
Hay quien rechaza los derechos homí-
nidos afirmando que son fruto de una confusión
conceptual. Sin embargo, aunque hay muchas
disputas filosóficas acerca de si existen derechos
naturales o derechos a recibir ayuda, sobre la
plausibilidad de las teorías del status y la elec-
ción, o sobre la concepción de los derechos como
triunfos o constricciones, la opinión mayoritaria
en todos esos debates es perfectamente com-
patible con el concepto de derechos simios. De
hecho, los derechos de los gorilas, orangutanes,
chimpancés, bonobos y humanos pueden defen-
derse desde cualquier posición en esos debates e
incluso desde cualquier combinación de posicio-
nes en esos debates.
Some reject hominid rights arguing they are the product of conceptual confusion. However, although there are many philosophical disputes regarding, for example, the existence of natural rights, of rights to be aided, as well as regarding the plausibility of the status or the choice theory of rights or the conception of rights as trumps or side-constraints, the majority opinion in all these debates is perfectly compatible with the concept of simian rights. In fact, gorilla, orang-utan, chimpanzee, bonobo and human rights can be defended from any position in those debates and even any combination of positions in those debates.
Some reject hominid rights arguing they are the product of conceptual confusion. However, although there are many philosophical disputes regarding, for example, the existence of natural rights, of rights to be aided, as well as regarding the plausibility of the status or the choice theory of rights or the conception of rights as trumps or side-constraints, the majority opinion in all these debates is perfectly compatible with the concept of simian rights. In fact, gorilla, orang-utan, chimpanzee, bonobo and human rights can be defended from any position in those debates and even any combination of positions in those debates.
Citation
item.page.embargo
Collections
Ir a Estadísticas
Sin licencia Creative Commons.